| 1 | A | Rutgers | 3:43.04 | | 56.67 | 1:53.41 | 2:48.41 | 3:43.04 | | (56.67) | (56.74) | (55.01) | (54.63) |
|
| 2 | A | St. John's University | 3:43.87 | | 57.29 | 1:52.44 | 2:47.40 | 3:43.87 | | (57.29) | (55.15) | (54.96) | (56.48) |
|
| 3 | A | Monmouth University | 3:44.29 | | 57.52 | 1:52.92 | 2:50.20 | 3:44.29 | | (57.52) | (55.41) | (57.28) | (54.10) |
|
| 4 | A | University at Albany | 3:46.89 | | 57.56 | 1:54.32 | 2:50.68 | 3:46.89 | | (57.56) | (56.76) | (56.37) | (56.21) |
|
| 5 | A | ASA College | 3:53.23 | | 57.93 | 1:55.76 | 2:56.75 | 3:53.23 | | (57.93) | (57.84) | (1:00.99) | (56.48) |
|
| 6 | A | Monroe College | 4:19.28 | | 1:12.86 | 2:12.11 | 3:15.86 | 4:19.28 | | (1:12.86) | (59.25) | (1:03.75) | (1:03.42) |
|