| 1 | A | St. Anthony's, NY | 4:03.37 | | 56.05 | 1:20.12 | 1:46.11 | 4:03.37 | | (56.05) | (24.07) | (26.00) | (2:17.27) |
|
| 2 | A | Kellenberg, NY | 4:08.63 | | 1:00.87 | 1:27.85 | 1:55.29 | 4:08.63 | | (1:00.87) | (26.99) | (27.45) | (2:13.34) |
|
| 3 | A | St. Francis Prep, NY | 4:13.11 | | 59.02 | 1:26.89 | 1:55.23 | 4:13.11 | | (59.02) | (27.87) | (28.35) | (2:17.88) |
|
| 4 | A | Archbishop Molloy, NY | 4:17.36 | | 1:03.52 | 1:32.06 | 1:57.97 | 4:17.36 | | (1:03.52) | (28.55) | (25.92) | (2:19.39) |
|
| 5 | A | Holy Trinity, NY | 4:19.94 | | 1:00.54 | 1:27.59 | 1:54.84 | 4:19.94 | | (1:00.54) | (27.06) | (27.25) | (2:25.10) |
|
| 6 | A | St. John Villa, NY | 4:28.35 | | 1:04.04 | 1:32.61 | 2:00.08 | 4:28.35 | | (1:04.04) | (28.58) | (27.47) | (2:28.27) |
|
