| 1 | Sowinski, Erik | Nike | 2:21.18 | | 28.10 | 56.50 | 1:25.54 | 1:54.52 | 2:21.18 | | (28.10) | (28.40) | (29.05) | (28.99) | (26.66) |
|
| 2 | Andrews, Robby | adidas | 2:21.23 | | 27.93 | 56.68 | 1:25.72 | 1:54.90 | 2:21.23 | | (27.93) | (28.76) | (29.04) | (29.18) | (26.34) |
|
| 3 | Windle, Drew | Ashland University | 2:22.91 | | 27.51 | 56.25 | 1:25.27 | 1:54.27 | 2:22.91 | | (27.51) | (28.75) | (29.02) | (29.01) | (28.65) |
|
| 4 | Murray, Declan | NJ-NY TC | 2:22.99 | | 28.22 | 56.75 | 1:25.35 | 1:54.43 | 2:22.99 | | (28.22) | (28.54) | (28.60) | (29.09) | (28.57) |
|
| 5 | Boylan Pett, Liam | NJ-NY TC | 2:23.44 | | 28.35 | 56.97 | 1:25.50 | 1:54.64 | 2:23.44 | | (28.35) | (28.63) | (28.54) | (29.14) | (28.81) |
|
| 6 | Solomon, Duane | Saucony | 2:24.31 | | 27.81 | 57.15 | 1:26.03 | 1:54.73 | 2:24.31 | | (27.81) | (29.35) | (28.88) | (28.70) | (29.59) |
|
| 7 | Marshall, Myles | Unnattached | 2:24.43 | | 28.19 | 57.28 | 1:26.76 | 1:56.70 | 2:24.43 | | (28.19) | (29.09) | (29.48) | (29.95) | (27.73) |
|
| 8 | Holdsworth, Derek | XMG Athletics | 2:25.25 | | 28.04 | 57.03 | 1:25.83 | 1:55.32 | 2:25.25 | | (28.04) | (29.00) | (28.80) | (29.49) | (29.94) |
|
| Reid, Nicholas | Shore AC | DNF | | 27.12 | 55.57 | 1:25.61 | | (27.12) | (28.46) | (30.05) |
|
| Iguider, Abdelaati | Nike | DNS | |
