| 1 | Kellenberg, NY | A | 4:08.22 | | 1:00.69 | 1:27.52 | 1:55.14 | 4:08.22 | | (1:00.69) | (26.83) | (27.63) | (2:13.09) |
|
| 2 | St. Anthony's, NY | A | 4:10.99 | | 1:01.96 | 1:27.67 | 1:54.59 | 4:10.99 | | (1:01.96) | (25.72) | (26.93) | (2:16.40) |
|
| 3 | St. John the Baptist, NY | A | 4:13.88 | | 1:02.30 | 1:29.41 | 1:57.32 | 4:13.88 | | (1:02.30) | (27.11) | (27.92) | (2:16.56) |
|
| 4 | Cardinal Spellman | A | 4:16.96 | | 59.69 | 1:27.49 | 1:55.56 | 4:16.96 | | (59.69) | (27.80) | (28.08) | (2:21.40) |
|
| 5 | Sacred Heart, NY | A | 4:23.38 | | 1:01.27 | 1:29.32 | 1:58.40 | 4:23.38 | | (1:01.27) | (28.05) | (29.09) | (2:24.99) |
|
| 6 | Holy Trinity, NY | A | 4:25.35 | | 1:01.67 | 1:28.78 | 1:57.17 | 4:25.35 | | (1:01.67) | (27.12) | (28.39) | (2:28.18) |
|
